Two for the Court

For the record here is the Prime Minister’s announcement of Justice Andromache Karakatsanis and Justice Michael J. Moldaver as the Government’s nominees for the Supreme Court of Canada. Both nominees have agreed to appear at an ad hoc parliamentary committee to answer questions of Members of Parliament on October 19. Blatchford’s reaction in the National Post is here, the Post’s editorial reaction and CTV’s story.

Justice Moldaver’s CV and Justice Karakatsanis’ CV

 

The news release singles out three judgments by Justice Moldaver as typical:
R. v. K.M., 2011 ONCA 252
R. v. Phillion, 2009 ONCA 202
Ontario Provincial Police v. The Cornwall Public Inquiry, 2008 ONCA 33
but then fails to provide a direct hyperlink. We have corrected that.

For Justice Karakatsanis the sample cases are:
Barrington v. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Ontario, 2011 ONCA 409
R. v. Cole, 2011 ONCA 218
R. v. Kahn, 2011 ONCA 173

Normally Slaw would link to the cases of the new nominees, but since the Federal Judicial Commissioner has done so, here are the lists of cases. We will have more substantive comment later.

The decisions listed in the following pages were taken from the subscriber accessed legal database “LexisNexis Canada” (“QL”) website after a search was conducted under the name of Justice Moldaver. The list should include decisions rendered by Mr. Justice Moldaver and by the Court where he was on the Panel, but not endorsements, since he was appointed to the Court of Appeal for Ontario on December 22, 1995, to the Ontario Court of Justice (General Division) on July 31, 1990 and to the High Court of Justice of the Supreme Court of Ontario on April 12, 1990.

The decisions of the Court of Appeal for Ontario can be found at:
http://www.ontariocourts.on.ca/decisions_index/en/.

The decisions of the Superior Court of Justice can be found at:
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/.

Where the cited decisions are not linked to either of the websites above, the citation is to the subscriber accessed legal data base, “LexisNexis Canada” (“QL”).

NOTE:
Case names in bold and italics indicate decisions written by Mr. Justice Moldaver.
Case names in italics indicate decisions written by the Court where Mr. Justice Moldaver was on the Panel of the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

Dissenting reasons written by Mr. Justice Moldaver are listed separately.


List of Decisions – Court of Appeal for Ontario

2011

Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
Rasouli v. Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre 2011 ONCA 482
Barker v. Barker 2011 ONCA 447
R. v. Hamilton 2011 ONCA 399
D’Alimonte v. Porretta 2011 ONCA 307
R. v. Ranger 2011 ONCA 311
R. v. Pittman 2011 ONCA 148
Khamis v. Noormohamed 2011 ONCA 127
R. v. Woodward 2011 ONCA 610
R. v. Badhwar 2011 ONCA 266
R. v. K.M. 2011 ONCA 252
Ontario (Community Safety and Correctional Services) v. Ontario (Information and Privacy Commissioner) 2011 ONCA 32

 


2010
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Gaya 2010 ONCA 860
R. v. Khalid 2010 ONCA 861
United States of America v. Nadarajah 2010 ONCA 859
United States of America v. Sriskandarajah 2010 ONCA 857
R. v. Amara 2010 ONCA 858
R. v. Khawaja 2010 ONCA 862
Corchis v. Essex Condominium Corporation No. 28 2010 ONCA 787
R. v. Cardwell 2010 ONCA 445
Rosso v. Gouveia 2010 ONCA 359
R. v. D.V.B. 2010 ONCA 291
R. v. Montague 2010 ONCA 141
MacKinnon Estate v. MacKinnon 2010 ONCA 170

2009
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Peng 2009 ONCA 921
R. v. Song 2009 ONCA 896
R. v. Schertzer 2009 ONCA 742
R. v. Baldasaro 2009 ONCA 676
R. v. Charette 2009 ONCA 310
R. v. Allen 2009 ONCA 261
Andrews v. Lundrigan 2009 ONCA 160
R. v. Bradley 2009 ONCA 175
R. v. Toy 2009 ONCA 176
R. v. Sidhu 2009 ONCA 81
Royal Bank of Canada v. Ren 2009 ONCA 48
R. v. Wint 2009 ONCA 52
R. v. Lewis 2009 ONCA 874
R. v. Bergauer-Free 2009 ONCA 610
R. v. Hay 2009 ONCA 398
Toronto Police Services Board v. (Ontario) Information and Privacy Commissioner 2009 ONCA 20
R. v. U.C. 2009 ONCA 367
R. v. Decator 2009 ONCA 290
R. v. Phillion 2009 ONCA 202
R. v. Imona-Russel [2009] O.J. No. 2889 (C.A.) (QL)

2008
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
AXA Insurance (Canada) v. Ani-Wall Concrete Forming Inc. 2008 ONCA 563
R. v. B.A. 2008 ONCA 556
R. v. J.S.R. 2008 ONCA 544
Johnson v. Milton (Town) 2008 ONCA 440
R. v. C.M. 2008 ONCA 430
McNeil v. Brewers Retail Inc. 2008 ONCA 405
R. v. M.J.O. 2008 ONCA 361
Lohse v. Fleming 2008 ONCA 307
PUC Distribution Inc. v. Brascan Energy Marketing Inc. 2008 ONCA 176
Ontario Provincial Police v. The Cornwall Public Inquiry 2008 ONCA 33
R. v. Laforet [2008] O.J. No. 5728 (C.A.) (QL)
R. v. Tedesco [2008] O.J. No. 1910 (C.A.) (QL)
Appin Realty Corporation v. Economical Mutual Insurance Company 2008 ONCA 95

2007
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Wilding 2007 ONCA 853
Proctor & Gamble Inc. v. Ontario (Finance) 2007 ONCA 784
R. v. Khan 2007 ONCA 779
Toronto Police Assocation v. Toronto Police Services Board 2007 ONCA 742
R. v. Daya 2007 ONCA 693
R. v. L.B. 2007 ONCA 596
Truscott (Re) 2007 ONCA 575
Isakhani v. Al-Saggaf 2007 ONCA 539
Authorson Estate v. Canada (Attorney General) 2007 ONCA 501
R. v. Soikie 2007 ONCA 473
R. v. Thornton 2007 ONCA 366
R. v. White 2007 ONCA 318
R. v. Spanos 2007 ONCA 241
R. v. Torsney 2007 ONCA 67
United States of America v. Thomlison 2007 ONCA 42

2006

Case NameCitationCourt of Appeal for OntarioR. v. VanezisNovember 10, 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 37954 (ON CA)

R. v. LabbeOctober 31 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 36608 (ON CA)

Truscott (Re)October 18 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 60337 (ON CA)

Truscott (Re)October 18 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 34698 (ON CA)

R. v. LinkieOctober 16 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 34408 (ON CA)

R. v. ZebedeeJune 29 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 22099 (ON CA)

R. v. CapraraJune 5, 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 18518 (ON CA)

Ontario Deputy Judges Association v. The Attorney General of Ontario May 25, 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 17250 (ON CA)

Solway v. Attorney in Fact in Canada for Lloyd’s UnderwritersMay 25, 2006 (C.A.)

2006 CanLII 17254 (ON CA)

2005

Case NameCitationCourt of Appeal for OntarioOntario Restaurant Hotel & Motel Association v. Toronto (City)October 7 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 36152 (ON CA)

Matrix Contractors & Building Services Inc. v. National Bank of CanadaJuly 13 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 24741 (ON CA)

R. v. JonesJune 28 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 22449 (ON CA)

Bozzo v. GiampaoloMay 25 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 17773 (ON CA)

Coady v. BoyleMay 11, 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 15456 (ON CA)

R. v. RichardsApril 25, 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 13028 (ON CA)

R. v. TriscasApril 22 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 12681 (ON CA)

R. v. Kporwodu and VenoApril 15, 2005 (C.A.)

[2005] O.J. No. 1405 (C.A.)(QL)

R. v. TrieuMarch 24, 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 7884 (ON CA)

Giroux (Executor and Trustee) v. Trillium Health CentreMarch 1, 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 1488 (ON CA)

Greenberg v. DanielsJanuary 17, 2005 (C.A.)

2005 CanLII 456 (ON CA)

2004

Case NameCitationCourt of Appeal for OntarioTrendle v. TrendleDecember 22, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 48649 (ON CA)

R. v. LaurinDecember 20, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 48156 (ON CA)

R. v. BaltovichDecember 2, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 45031 (ON CA)

Rogacki v. BelzSeptember 1, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 21439 (ON CA)

R. v. B., J.June 16, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 39056 (ON CA)

United States of America v. McDowellMarch 10, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 36125 (ON CA)

R. v. BennettMarch 19, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 36124 (ON CA)

R. v. ClarkJanuary 26, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 12038 (ON CA)

R. v. Willard[2004] O.J. No. 5585 (C.A.) (QL)R. v. LaurinDecember 20, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 48156 (ON CA)

Truscott (Re)December 14, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 47148 (ON CA)

Banihashem-Bakhtiari v. Axes Investments Inc.March 17, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 36112 (ON CA)

Banihashem – Bakhtiari v. Axes Investments Inc.February 6, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 5996 (ON CA)

Celanese Canada Inc. v. Murray Demolition Corp.October 1, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 31856 (ON CA)

Granite Power Corp. v. OntarioAugust 3, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 44786 (ON CA)

R. v. HunterFebruary 6, 2004 (C.A.)

2004 CanLII 32107 (ON CA)

2003
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Chrisanthopoulos December 29, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 50105 (ON CA)
Canada (Minister of Justice) v. D. P. R. 2004 CanLII 39039 (ON CA)
R. v. Brooks September 29, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 57389 (ON CA)
R. v. Elliott December 4, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 24447 (ON CA)
R. v. Transport Robert (1973) Ltée November 14, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 7741 (ON CA)
Commissioner of Competition v. Falconbridge Ltd. May 1, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 52144 (ON CA)
R. v. Sodhi September 8, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 52179 (ON CA)
R. v. McGee July 30, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 7915 (ON CA)
R. v. Humphrey February 20, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 6855 (ON CA)
R. v. Janeteas February 5, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 57385 (ON CA)
Felde v. Vein and Laser Medical Centre December 3, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 19431 (ON CA)
R. v. De la Cruz August 22, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 42069 (ON CA)
R. v. De la Cruz May 26, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 45233 (ON CA)
R. v. Cuming July 30, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 30676 (ON CA)
R. v. Reid July 4, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 14779 (ON CA)
Susin v. Swartz May 23, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 29236 (ON CA)
R. v. Napa Valley Private Winery Inc. February 27, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 52136 (ON CA)
K., M.S. v. T., T.L. February 7, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 O.J. No.352 (C.A.) (QL)
R. v. M., J.S. January 20, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 10419 (ON CA)
R. v. B., C. January 9, 2003 (C.A.)

2003 CanLII 32894 (ON CA)

2002

 
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. McLean December 18, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 11684 (ON CA)
R. v. Douglas December 11, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 38799 (ON CA)
R. v. McKenzie August 2, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 45009 (ON CA)
R. v. Shirley February 21, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 20102 (ON CA)
R. v. Nguyen January 8, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 44910 (ON CA)
R. v. Young November 18, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 17650 (ON CA)
R. v. Bouhsass November 4, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 45109 (ON CA)
R. v. D., D. March 21, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 44915 (ON CA)
Mack v. Attorney General of Canada September 13, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 45062 (ON CA)
R. v. Hurrell July 19, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 45007(ON CA)
R. v. S., E. April 23, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 49353 (ON CA)
R. v. Baltrusaitis February 12, 2002 (C.A.)

2002 CanLII 36440 (ON CA)

2001
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Balchand December 7, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 5649 (ON CA)
Canada Post Corporation v. Canadian Union of Postal Workers November 15, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8616 (ON CA)
R. v. Greco October 25, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8608 (ON CA)
Andersen Consulting Ltd. v. Canada (Attorney General) September 10, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8587 (ON CA)
Administrator of the Penetanguishene Mental Health Centre v. Ontario (Attorney General) May 31, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8543 (ON CA)
R. v. Bedard May 23, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8536 (ON CA)
R. v. Phillips January 16, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24121 (ON CA)
Sullivan (Estate of) v. Bond August 2, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 8584 (ON CA)
R. v. P., D. July 20, 2001 (C.A.)

[2001] O.J. No. 2865 (C.A.)(QL)
R. v. Brissett May 23, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 4980 (ON CA)
A & A Jewellers Limited v. Royal Bank of Canada March 9, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24012 (ON CA)
R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation March 2, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24044 (ON CA)
Parsons v. Canadian Red Cross Society January 26, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24094 (ON CA)
R. v. Katwaru January 25, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24112 (ON CA)
R. v. Taylor January 22, 2001 (C.A.)

2001 CanLII 24190 (ON CA)

2000

 
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Ploumis December 13, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 17033 (ON CA)
Royal Trust Corporation of Canada v. 502759 Ontario Ltd. June 23, 2000 (revised June 24, 2000) (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 5738 (ON CA)
R. v. Thompson June 19, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 5746 (ON CA)
Ontario (Attorney General) v. Ontario Public Service Employees Union December 7, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 17008 (ON CA)
R. v. Krugel February 16, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 5660 (ON CA)
R. v. Culliton January 20, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 1093 (ON CA)
Ontario v. Grievance Settlement Board September 18, 2000 (revised January 8, 2001) (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 16854 (ON CA)
Bank of Montreal v. Korico Enterprises Lmited September 8, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 16833 (ON CA)
Kerr v. Quigley et al January 12, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 5622 (ON CA)
R. v. MacDonald July 13, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 16799 (ON CA)
R. v. Zhang May 10, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 3485 (ON CA)
Algonquin Wildlands League v. Ontario (Minister of Natural Resources) (addendum) February 10, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 O.J. No. 295 (C.A.)(QL)
R. v. Keeper May 3, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 2375 (ON CA)
R. v. McNeill April 13, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 4897 (ON CA)
R. v. Karthiresu February 14, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 6008 (ON CA)
R. v. Bernardo March 29, 2000 (C.A.)

2000 CanLII 5678 (ON CA)

1999
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Roy December 13, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2293 (ON CA)
Thomas v. Bell Helmets Inc. November 16, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 9312 (ON CA)
T. I. v. L., L. November 10, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3806 (ON CA)
M., A. v. Benes November 10, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3807 (ON CA)
789538 Ontario Limited v. Gambin Associates October 25, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 9287 (ON CA)
789538 Ontario Limited v. Gambin Associates December 13, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3810 (ON CA)
Lillie v. Bisson October 7, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2860 (ON CA)
R. v. W., L.K. September 28, 1999 (revised November 30, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3791 (ON CA)
R. v. H., H. September 23, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 1220 (ON CA)
Midas Canada Limited v. 846709 Ontario Ltd. September 20, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 1447 (ON CA)
R. v. P., V. September 13, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3774 (ON CA)
R. v. Barnes January 19, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3782 (ON CA)
R. v. K., A. September 13, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3793 (ON CA)
R. v. Mach July 13, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3752 (ON CA)
R. v. Tahal July 5, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2517 (ON CA)
R. v. Lauda June 17, 1999 (revised June 23, 1999) (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 970 (ON CA)
R. v. Coutts June 9, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3742 (ON CA)
R. v. Allen May 14, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 3724 (ON CA)
Cowie Industrial Developments Limited v. National Clearance Warehouse Ltd. April 27, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2114 (ON CA)
Walker v. York Finch General Hospital and The Canadian Red Cross Society March 10, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2158 (ON CA)
Alchimowicz v. Schram January 18, 1999 (C.A.)

1999 CanLII 2655 (ON CA)

1998

 
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. W., E. December 8, 1998 (C.A.)

1998 CanLII 7196 (ON CA)
Stuart v. Hutchins September 14, 1998 (C.A.)

1998 CanLII 7163 (ON CA)
Walsh v. Walsh July 20, 1998 (C.A.)

1998 CanLII 7134 (ON CA)
Royal Bank of Canada v. Bruce Industrial Sales Ltd. 1998 CanLII 3050 (ON CA)
Alderson v. Callaghan 1998 CanLII 895 (ON CA)
R. v. French 1998 CanLII 1325 (ON CA)
French Estate v. Ontario (Attorney General) 1998 CanLII 1771 (ON CA)
602533 Ontario Inc. v. Shell Canada Ltd. 1998 CanLII 1775 (ON CA)

1997
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. Puskas 1997 CanLII 1159 (ON CA)
R. v. Harris 1997 CanLII 6317 (ON CA)
R. v. Bourguignon 1997 CanLII 1917 (ON CA)
R. v. Ramos 1997 CanLII 1425 (ON CA)
Ligate v. Richardson 1997 CanLII 650 (ON CA)
R. v. Gilling 1997 CanLII 837 (ON CA)
Opie v. Zegil 1997 CanLII 1520 (ON CA)
R. v. Joudrie 1997 CanLII 537 (ON CA)
R. v. Betker 1997 CanLII 1902 (ON CA)
McLeod v. Castlepoint Development Corporation 1997 CanLII 12080 (ON CA)
R. v. Morin 1997 CanLII 12082 (ON CA)
Smallwood v. Hill 1997 CanLII 3522 (ON CA)

1996
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
Butterfield (Guardian of) v. Butterfield Estate 1996 CanLII 1117 (ON CA)
R. v. S.A.S.R. 1996 CanLII 797 (ON CA)
Montani v. Matthews 1996 CanLII 1387 (ON CA)
R. v. G.W.R 1996 CanLII 613 (ON CA)
B. (D.) v. Children’s Air Society of Durham Region 1996 CanLII 1067 (ON CA)
R. v. Pintar 1996 CanLII 712 (ON CA)
R. v. A.F 1996 CanLII 10222 (ON CA)
R. v. Milne 1996 CanLII 508 (ON CA)

List of Decisions – Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)


1995
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
R. v. Johnson [1995] O.J. No. 3764 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Clarke Transport Canada Inc. 1995 CanLII 7327 (ON SC)
R. v. Camilleri [1995] O.J. No. 5023 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Laing [1995] O.J. No. 4167 (S.C.J.) (QL)
Rotstein v. North York (City) Chief Building Official [1995] O.J. No. 4575 (QL); 29 M.P.L.R. (2d) 305 (Gen. Div.)
Hasan v. 260 Wellesley Residence Ltd. [1995] O.J. No. 1909 (QL); 24 O.R. (3d) 335 (Div. Ct.)
Vanderschot, Horne & Dempsey v. North Easthope (Township) [1995] O.J. No. 4820 (QL); 24 O.R. (3d) 286 (Div. Ct.)
Windsor Board of Education v. Windsor Roman Catholic Separate School Board [1995] O.J. No. 1689 (QL); 24 O.R. (3d) 62 (Div. Ct.)
Caterair Chateau Canada Ltd. v. Ontario (Minister of Labour) [1995] O.J. No. 1674 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
R. v. Marquard [1995] O.J. No. 3050 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
Canada Colors & Chemicals Ltd. v. Tenneco Canada Inc. [1995] O.J. No. 25 (QL); 21 O.R. (3d) 438 (Div. Ct.)

1994
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
Latif v. Ontario (Human Rights Commission) [1994] O.J. No. 3988 (QL); 79 O.A.C. 33 (Div. Ct.)
E.S. Fox Ltd. v. Millwright District Council [1994] O.J. No. 4373 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
Van Dehwal v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. [1994] O.J. No. 4421 (QL); 20 O.R. (3d) 401 (Div. Ct.)
Societe Sepic S.A. v. Aga Stone Ltd. [1994] O.J. No. 3991 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
R. v. Anderson [1994] O.J. No. 2059 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Millar 1994 CanLII 7558 (ON SC)
R. v. Linton 1994 CanLII 7272 (ON SC)
Stelco Inc. v. United Steelworkers of America, Local 1005 [1994] O.J. No. 185 (QL); 17 O.R. (3d) 218 (Div. Ct.)
R. v. Adair [1994] O.J. No. 3265 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Pentecost [1994] O.J. No. 4213 (QL); 3 M.V.R. (3d) 155 (Gen. Div.)
Booth v. Huxter [1994] O.J. No. 52 (QL); 16 O.R. (3d) 528 (Div. Ct.)

1993
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
St. Louis (Litigation guardian of) v. Feleki (Ont. Div. Ct.) [1993] O.J. No. 3144 (QL); 107 D.L.R. (4th) 767 (Div. Ct.)
Hemlo Gold Mines Inc. v. Royal Oak Mines Inc. 1993 CanLII 5595 (ON SC)
Ontario (Human Rights Comm.) v. Gaines Pet Foods Corp. 1993 CanLII 5605 (ON SC)
College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario v. Mohan [1993] O.J. No. 2842 (QL); 16 O.R. (3d) 62 (Div. Ct.)
R. v. Won [1993] O.J. No. 3325 (QL) (S.C.J.)
Armstrong v. Ontario (Regional Assessment Commissioner, Region No. 14) [1993] O.J. No. 2555 (QL); 16 O.R. (3d) 156 (Div. Ct.)
Graham v. Millman [1993] O.J. No. 1970 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. C.I. [1993] O.J. No. 1717 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Andriopolous [1993] O.J. No. 2321 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Brooks [1993] O.J. No. 1396 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Melaragni [1993] O.J. No. 782 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Brooker (Ont. Ct. (Gen. Div.) ) [1993] O.J. No. 284 (Gen. Div.) (QL)

1992
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
R. v. Hachez [1992] O.J. No. 2712 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp. (CBC) [1992] O.J. No. 2229 (QL); 77 C.C.C. (3d) 341 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Hachez [1992] O.J. No. 3058 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Melaragni [1992] O.J. No. 2294 (QL); 72 C.C.C. (3d) 339 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Hachez; R. v. Hieronymi; R. v. Holder; R. v. Goodman [1992] O.J. No. 2444 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Melaragni [1992] O.J. No. 4178 (QL); 75 C.C.C. (3d) 546 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Melaragni [1992] O.J. No. 4177 (QL); 76 C.C.C. (3d) 78 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Melaragni [1992] O.J. No. 4176 (QL); 73 C.C.C. (3d) 348 (Gen. Div.)

1991
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
Sun v. Hong Kong [1991] O.J. No. 2011 (QL); 6 O.R. (3d) 104 (Gen. Div.)
Toronto Harbour Commissioners v. Disero [1991] O.J. No. 1922 (QL); 5 O.R. (3d) 585 (Gen. Div.)
Citibank Canada v. Cameron [1991] O.J. No. 3674 (QL); 7 O.R. (3d) 777 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Durham [1991] O.J. No. 1036 (QL); 66 C.C.C. (3d) 66 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Khan [1991] O.J. No. 637 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Christakos [1991] O.J. No. 3579 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
Richland Investment Corp. v. Sinclair [1991] O.J. No. 23 (Gen. Div.) (QL)

1990
Case Name Citation
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
Wood v. Gateway of Uxbridge Properties Inc. [1990] O.J. No. 2254 (QL); 75 O.R. (2d) 769 (Gen. Div.)
Kodak Canada Inc. v. Jesi Estates Inc. [1990] O.J. No. 3409 (Gen. Div.) (QL)
R. v. Butcher [1990] O.J. No. 3408 (QL); 5 C.R.R. (2d) 380 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Hughes [1990] O.J. No. 3160 (QL); 28 M.V.R. (2d) 316 (Gen. Div.)
R. v. Moore [1990] O.J. No. 3420 (QL); 63 C.C.C. (3d) 85 (Gen. Div.)

List of Decisions – High Court of Justice of the Supreme Court of Ontario


1990
Case Name Citation
High Court of Justice of the Supreme Court of Ontario
Doe v. Metropolitan Toronto (Municipality) Commissioners of Police [1990] O.J. No. 1584 (QL); 74 O.R. (2d) 225 (Div. Ct.)
Redhill v. Ontario Health Insurance Plan [1990] O.J. No. 1504 (QL); 75 O.R. (2d) 258 (Div. Ct.)
Shomair v. Ontario Health Insurance Plan [1990] O.J. No. 1503 (QL); 75 O.R. (2d) 266 (Div. Ct.)
Grossman v. Woolf (Ont. Div. Ct.) [1990] O.J. No. 1332 (QL); 40 O.A.C. 154 (Div. Ct.)
Biscotti v. Ontario Securities Commission [1990] O.J. No. 1323 (QL); 74 O.R. (2d) 119 (Div. Ct.)
R. v. Chan [1990] O.J. No. 2121 (H.C.J.) (QL)
Kaptsis v. Macias [1990] O.J. No. 1333 (QL); 74 O.R. (2d) 189 (H.C.J.)
Stefanovska v. Kok [1990] O.J. No. 865 (QL); 73 O.R. (2d) 368 (H.C.J.)
Henderson v. Henderson Estate [1990] O.J. No. 833 (QL); 73 O.R. (2d) 616 (H.C.J.)
Wade v. Laser Friendly, Inc. [1990] O.J. No. 832 (QL)

Dissenting Reasons for Judgment Rendered by Mr. Justice Moldaver

Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
R. v. V.Y. 2010 ONCA 544
R. v. Sarrazin [2000] O.J. No. 2047 (C.A.) (QL)
R. v. Find 1999 CanLII 2270 (ON CA)
R. v. A.R.B. [1998] O.J. No. 3648 (QL); 41 O.R. (3d) 361 (C.A.)
Ontario Court of Justice (General Division)
Dulmage v. Ontario (Police Complaints Commissioner) 1994 CanLII 8773 (Div. Ct.) (ON SC)
Metropolitan Toronto (Municipality) v. Toronto [1994] O.J. No. 2274 (QL); 20 O.R. (3d) 142 (Div. Ct.)

Decisions Rendered by Mr. Justice Moldaver
and Heard on Appeal by the Supreme Court of Canada

Judgments rendered by the Supreme Court of Canada can be found at:
http://www.scc-csc.gc.ca/decisions/index-eng.asp

Case name and Citation On Appeal From Disposition Involvement of Moldaver J.A.
Nadarajah v. United States of America, SCC File No.: 34013, [2011] S.C.C.A. No. 64 (QL) 2010 ONCA 859 Leave granted June 30, 2011 – not yet argued. Reasons for judgment written by the Court
Sriskandarajah v. United States of America, SCC File No.: 34009, [2011] S.C.C.A. No. 63 (QL) 2010 ONCA 857 Leave granted June 30, 2011 – not yet argued. Reasons for judgment written by the Court
R. v. Khawaja, SCC File No. 34103, [2011] S.C.C.A. No. 80 (QL) 2010 ONCA 862 Leave granted June 30, 2011 – not yet argued. Reasons for judgment written by the Court
R. v. Topp, 2011 SCC 43 2009 ONCA 828 Appeal Dismissed Reasons for appeal book endorsement written by the Court
R. v. V.Y., 2011 SCC 22 2010 ONCA 544 Appeal Dismissed Moldaver J.A. wrote dissenting reasons of the Court of Appeal
Pro Swing Inc. v. Elta Golf Inc., 2006 SCC 52, [2006] 2 S.C.R. 612 2004 CanLII 870 (ON CA) Appeal Dismissed Reasons for endorsement written by the Court
Celanese Canada Inc. v. Murray Demolition Corp., 2006 SCC 36, [2006] 2 S.C.R. 189 2004 CanLII 31856(ON CA) Appeal Allowed Moldaver J.A. wrote the decision of the Court of Appeal
Penetanguishene Mental Health Centre v. Ontario (Attorney General), 2004 SCC 20, [2004] 1 S.C.R. 498 2001 CanLII 8543 (ON CA) Appeal Allowed Moldaver J.A. wrote the decision of the Court of Appeal
Boston v. Boston, 2001 SCC 43, [2001] 2 S.C.R. 413 1999 CanLII 3069 (ON CA) Appeal Allowed Reasons for endorsement written by the Court
R. v. Find, 2001 SCC 32, [2001] 1 S.C.R. 863 1999 CanLII 2270 (ON CA) Appeal Dismissed Moldaver J.A. wrote dissenting reasons of the Court of Appeal
Jesuit Fathers of Upper Canada v. Guardian Insurance Co. of Canada, 2006 SCC 21, [2006] 1 S.C.R. 744 2004 CanLII 36172 (ON CA) Appeal Dismissed Reasons for endorsement written by the Court

The decisions listed in the following pages were taken from the subscriber accessed legal database “LexisNexis Canada” (“QL”) website after a search was conducted under the name of Justice Karakatsanis. The list should include decisions rendered by Madam Justice Karakatsanis and by the Court where she was on the Panel, but not endorsements, since she was appointed to the Court of Appeal for Ontario on March 26, 2010 and to the Superior Court of Justice on November 21, 2002.

The decisions of the Court of Appeal for Ontario can be found at:
http://www.ontariocourts.on.ca/decisions_index/en/

The decisions of the Superior Court of Justice can be found at:
http://www.canlii.org/en/on/onsc/

Where the cited decisions are not linked to either of the websites above, the citation is to the subscriber accessed legal data base, “LexisNexis Canada” (“QL”).

NOTE:
Case names in bold and italics indicate decisions written by Madam Justice Karakatsanis.
Case names in italics indicate decisions written by the Court where Madam Justice Karakatsanis was on the Panel of the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

List of Decisions – Court of Appeal for Ontario


2011

Case NameCitationCourt of Appeal for OntarioDundee Precious Metals Inc. v. Marsland2011 ONCA 594Hollinger Inc. (Re)2011 ONCA 579Hungary v. Toth2011 ONCA 532Cunningham v. Moran2011 ONCA 476R. v. Beausoleil2011 ONCA 471Ranger v. Penterman2011 ONCA 412Barrington v. Institute of Chartered Accountants of Ontario2011 ONCA 409R. v. R.B.2011 ONCA 328R. v. Valovic2011 ONCA 320R. v. Cole2011 ONCA 218Gagne v. Gagne2011 ONCA 188R. v. Khan2011 ONCA 173First Ontario Realty Corp. v. Deng2011 ONCA 542189205 Ontario Inc. v. Springdale Pizza Depot Ltd.2011 ONCA 467


2010
Case Name Citation
Court of Appeal for Ontario
Simonin Estate v. Simonin 2010 ONCA 900
Indcondo Building Corp. v. Sloan 2010 ONCA 890
R. v. Palmer 2010 ONCA 804
R. v. Brunet 2010 ONCA 781
Slapsys (1406393 Ontario Inc.) v. Abrams 2010 ONCA 676
Nashid v. Michael 2010 ONCA 661
Wangler v. Fort Erie (Town) 2010 ONCA 658
Jaffer v. York University 2010 ONCA 654
R. v. Rashid 2010 ONCA 591
R. v. Bissonnette 2010 ONCA 585
R. v. Capobianco 2010 ONCA 589
Black v. Breeden 2010 ONCA 547
S.N.S. Industrial Products Ltd. v. Bank of Montreal 2010 ONCA 500

List of Decisions – Superior Court of Justice


2010

Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
McCann and Guffie v. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2010 ONSC 65 (CanLII)
Polywheels Inc. (Re) 2010 ONSC 1265 (CanLII)
Canada (Attorney General) v. Giacomelli [2010] O.J. No. 844 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
R. v. Tremblay [2010] O.J. No. 3450 (Div. Ct.) (QL)

2009
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
Johnson v. Lombard Canada Ltd. [2009] O.J. No. 5892 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario v. Peel Regional Police 2009 CanLII 55315 (ON SCDC)
Bot Construction Ltd. v. Ontario (Ministry of Transportation) 99 O.R. (3d) 104; [2009] O.J. No. 3590 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
Prestige Toys Ltd. v. Registrar, Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 2009 CanLII 43657 (ON SCDC)
2038724 Ontario Ltd. v. Quizno’s Canada Restaurant Corporation 2009 CanLII 23374 (ON SCDC)
Canadian College of Business and Computers Inc. v. Superintendent, Under The Private Career Colleges Act 2009 CanLII 38499 (ON SCDC)
Boone v. Advantage Car and Truck Rentals Ltd. 2009 CanLII 54314 (ON SCDC)
Nishnawbe Aski Nation v. Eden 2009 CanLII 30144 (ON SCDC)
Schuit Plastering & Stucco Inc. v. Ontario Labour Relations Board 2009 CanLII 30145 (ON SCDC)
Toronto Hydro-Electric System Ltd. v. Ontario Energy Board 2009 CanLII 30148 (ON SCDC)
Goselin v. Registrar, Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 2009 CanLII 15894 (ON SCDC)
1522491 Ontario Inc. v. Stewart Esten Professional Corp. 2009 CanLII 15656 (ON SCDC)
Assaf v. Hew [2009] O.J. No. 6191 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
Aird v. Ontario (Workplace Safety and Insurance Appeals Tribunal) [2009] O.J. No. 6183 (Div. Ct.) (QL)
Ceci v. Lippa 2009 CanLII 7761 (ON SCDC)
Toronto and Region Conservation Authority v. Gadzala 2009 CanLII 30143 (ON SCDC)
G. Raymond Chang Ltd. v. ShopCast Television (TV) Inc. 2009 CanLII 4851 (ON SCDC)
Bender v. Piccininni [2009] O.J. No. 568 (Div. Ct.) (QL)

2008
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
St. George and St. Rueiss Coptic Orthodox Church v. Toronto (City) 2008 CanLII 68888 (ON SCDC)
William Ashley China Ltd. v. Toronto (City) 2008 CanLII 56705 (ON SCDC)
1392290 Ontario Ltd. v. Ajax (Town) 2008 CanLII 78090 (ON SCDC)
Registrar, Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario v. 2008221 Ontario Inc. (Pilot Tavern) 2008 CanLII 46925 (ON SCDC)
R. v. Savoury [2008] O.J. No. 2896 (S.C.J.) (QL)
R. v. Milani 2008 CanLII 15773 (ON SCDC)

2007
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
R. v. Barrett [2007] O.J. No. 3680 (S.C.J.) (QL)

2006
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
Fox v. Fox 2006 CanLII 21065 (ON SC)
Moscoe v. DiFelice 2006 CanLII 63730 (ON SC)

2005
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
Pinizzotto v. Pinizzotto 2005 CanLII 34355 (ON SC)
Ji v. Zhang [2005] O.J. No. 3934 (S.C.J.) (QL)
Tao v. Li 2005 CanLII 33044 (ON SC)
C.B. v. Sawadsky [2005] O.J. No. 3682 (S.C.J.) (QL)
LGL Ltd. v. Blairhampton Properties Inc. 2005 CanLII 14144 (ON SC)
R. v. Kamateh [2005] O.J. No. 6328 (S.C.J.) (QL)
Chun v. Primmum Insurance Co. [2005] O.J. No. 6384 (S.C.J.) (QL)


2004

Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
C. and M. Holdings Ltd. v. Tiffany Gate Ltd. [2004] O.J. No. 6201 (S.C.J.) (QL)
R. v. Kamateh [2004] O.J. No. 6199 (S.C.J.) (QL)
R. v. Jacobson [2004] O.J. No. 5682 (S.C.J.) (QL)
Nussbaum v. Nussbaum 2004 CanLII 23086 (ON SC)
Kontopidis v. Coventry Lane Automobiles Ltd. 2004 CanLII 66314 (ON SC)
Dagarsho Holdings Ltd. v. Bluestone 2004 CanLII 11271 (ON SC)
Brunetta v. Brampton (City) 2004 CanLII 24298 (ON SC)
Gore Mutual Insurance Co. v. 1443249 Ontario Ltd. 2004 CanLII 27736 (ON SC)
Kontopidis v. Coventry Lane Automobiles Ltd. 2004 CanLII 16875 (ON SC)
Design Home Associates v. Raviv 2004 CanLII 46680 (ON SC)
F1 Software Inc. v. Broadview Software Inc. 2004 CanLII 20057 (ON SC)
Panizovski v. Veljanoski 2004 CanLII 18327 (ON SC)
Gore Mutual Insurance Co. v. 1443249 Ontario Ltd 2004 CanLII 23560 (ON SC)
1427814 Ontario Ltd. v. 3697584 Canada Inc. 2004 CanLII 16681 (ON SC)
Springhill Gardens Developments Inc. v. Kent 2004 CanLII 15057 (ON SC)
Saved by technology Inc. v. Thomas 2004 CanLII 25520 (ON SC)

2003
Case Name Citation
Superior Court of Justice
Westar Electrical Contractors Inc. v. 1342713 Ontario Ltd. 2003 CanLII 6830 (ON SC)
Don Area Co-Operative Homes v. Sanford 2003 CanLII 22280 (ON SC)
Saved by Technology Inc. v. Thomas 2003 CanLII 36377 (ON SC)
Mount Sinai Hospital v. Municipal Property Assessment Corp. 2003 CanLII 3014 (ON SC)
Ostroff v. Ramnarine [2003] O.J. No. 3818 (S.C.J.) (QL)
Bekah v. Three for One Pizza 2003 CanLII 64302 (ON SC)
Syntax Systems Ltd. v. Mid-Range Computer Group Inc. 2003 CanLII 29363 (ON SC)
Campbell v. Szoke 2003 CanLII 2291 (ON SC)
A.J.K. v. S.L.M. 2003 CanLII 1969 (ON SC)
Gauthier v. Gauthier 2003 CanLII 64348 (ON SC)
Fantin v. Fantin 2003 CanLII 2114 (ON SC)

Judgments of the Supreme Court of Canada can be found at:
http://www.scc-csc.gc.ca/decisions/index-eng.asp

Case name & citation Status Supreme Court Court File No.
Breeden v. Black, 2010 ONCA 547 Leave to appeal granted December 16, 2010
Appeal Heard March 22, 2011: judgment reserved.
33900

Comments are closed.