It’s Not “Getting Even”, It’s Restoring the Rule of Law

In countries in which a regime committed to the rule of law succeeds or otherwise vanquishes a regime known for corruption, self-dealing, attacks on the populace and other wrong-doing, the new government faces an existential question: hold the former regime to account or to move on.

Is the focus to be on the past or the future? Some hopefully transformative regimes, while not exactly holding the regime to account, implement a truth and reconciliation commission that avoids findings of fault; such a commission may be said to ensure the country and its people know what happened while at the same time alleviating concern that those who did wrong or supported those who did wrong will continue to imperil the country’s future. Perhaps if the wrongdoers will not face consequences (other than denunciation?), they will tell the truth about what they or others did. And perhaps it also carries less of a whiff of vindictiveness by the winners.

Following the American midterm elections with their “bluenami”, the Democrats’ choice appears to be between “moving on” and insisting on accountability. A truth and reconciliation commission has not been part of the conversation, although investigations alone may be akin to this. Impeachment and criminal charges are another matter.

If the Democrats decide to pursue accountability, how they choose to do this and what they replace the former regime with will matter to restoring the United States’ reputation and relations with Europe, Canada and others. To be clear, the new and returning legislators will also need to determine which of the issues they will prioritize among those the American public has identified as most important to them, such as ending the war with Iran and the related issue of “affordability”, among others. The Democrats cannot all be about accountability. The question is: should some of what they do be? And: if they decide to put it aside, what is the cost?

What role does the law play in all of this? As we all know, the law and legal processes, such as investigations, can be used to abuse or to deliver justice, albeit the latter imperfectly. The goal of accountability is to return law to its rightful role, not as a weapon but as a mechanism to find truth. And law is effective only when consequences follow appropriate legal processes when they have resulted in a finding of wrongdoing.

When accepted processes have been dislocated, especially to the extent that a failure to observe the law – or to abuse the law – risks turning a democracy into an autocracy, the response of the successor decision-makers will mark how it defines itself in the future. A country is in part defined not only by what it is in the present, but also by what it treats as memories: in short, how it has written its history.

I was reminded of the significance of facing past wrong when I attended a one-night only performance by Saul Rubinek and Seana McKenna of “Kristallnacht: The Night of Broken Glass” at the ROM in Toronto recently.

The reading was in part about Kristallnacht but it was also broader. Rubinek and McKenna covered a great deal of ground in the space of less than an hour, reading in part from Rubinek’s book, All in the Telling: A Somewhat True Story. In one passage, Rubinek’s father had been given the gift of a scholarly book about the history of the town where he and Rubinek’s mother had lived; he discovered it reduced the Jewish life there to three pages, omitting the ill-treatment and killings that had occurred at the town at the hands of the Nazis. This erasure sanitized the history of the town: without inclusion of Jewish history, the town’s history was flawed, incomplete and, indeed, false.

Although not at the same level as expunging Jewish experience under the Nazis, the Democrats, in deciding whether they will demand accountability face an existential moment, one akin to the investigation following the January 6th attack on the Capitol. Its new legislators must resolve the challenge of reconciling the demands of responding to the complaints voters identified, reversing policy decisions by the previous administration with which it disagrees and making it clear that what that administration has wrought does not conform to the principles and norms of American governance and to the rule of law.

As of January 3, 2027, the Democrats will have the means to take steps towards potentially holding the current administration and those in the penumbra they created accountable for their contraventions of the rule of law, their disregard of constitutional principles and their undermining of institutional integrity. I say “potentially” because the Democrats are already divided on whether they want to invoke the processes for doing so or to let bygones be bygones and focus entirely on the more tangible and concrete issues that the country faces.

The current minority leader in the House of Representatives, Hakim Jeffries, likely to be the next Speaker, has stated, “The American people don’t want us to get even. They want us to get things done on their behalf because life is way too expensive” (The New Republic, November 4, 2026).

A number of Canadian commentators seem to be opposed to spending much time or effort on accountability, possibly because they see doing so as risking the Democrats success in 2028.

As Andrew Coyne, points out, that “[t]he Democrats, for their part, will have one eye on the 2028 elections, and may hesitate to properly confront [Trump], for fear of being painted as the ‘do-nothing Congress,’ more interested in ‘persecuting the President’ than ‘working for the American people.’” (The Globe and Mail, “U.S. midterms are a rebuke to the Republicans, but not the wipeout they deserve”, November 5, 2026)

Another Canadian commentator describes identifying and acting on accountability as “a vengeance agenda”, with “[t]he progressives want[ing] to see the last vestiges of MAGA crushed beyond recognition. They want all gas, no brakes when it comes to seeking a retribution they feel is justified and deserved.” (Gary Mason, The Globe and Mail, “The new voices of the U.S. Democratic Party begin to craft a different narrative”, November 5, 2026)

And yet a third cautions the Democrats about “wast[ing] … the next two years dragging Trump through a sideshow of impeachment proceedings…” (Kelly McParland, The National Post, “Americans take first step to repair Trump’s damage”, November 4, 2026).

In the United States, Representative Jamie Raskin, who will likely chair the House Judiciary Committee, has been adamant that the Trump administration be held to account. For example, Raskin has said, “’We want the masks off, and we want the cameras turned on, and we want to re-impose the Constitution and the rule of law on ICE,” Raskin said. “It cannot operate outside of the rule of law in our country.’” (Capital News Service, November 6 [?], 2026)

I do not believe the Democrats have a choice: it is crucial that they make it clear that the Trump administration’s actions and Trump’s own conduct are contrary to the constitution, the institutional balance of power and the operation of law in the United States. There is no question that the Democrats will have to respond to the domestic issues that motivated many American voters to desert Donald Trump (because he got his wish, I believe, that people voted as if he were on the ballot). And they cannot be distracted from being seen to do that and doing that effectively. Yet it is possible to work on more than one level at a time and their efforts over the next wo years must be to hold the Trump administration accountable.

Despite efforts to treat the “affordability” type of issue and accountability as binary, they are related. For example, corruption in the Trump administration, and particularly in relation to Trump and his family, was a major factor for some voters in voting Democratic. Corruption means that decisions that should have benefitted the American populace have increased the wealth of Trump himself, his sons, his son-in-law, Jared Kushner and friend, Steve Witkoff and others. Kushner and Witkoff’s so-called “envoy” role in Ukraine and the Middle East have allowed them to make lucrative deals for their self-benefit, for example. Corruption is an ethical issue that likely also involves legal wrongdoing and related to decisions that affect everyday issues.

Many voters were motivated to vote against the Republicans because of the prosaic issue of the price of gas, as well as affordability more generally (in part the result of the high price of diesel); yet this issue is related to the war in Iran, both the decision to begin it without congressional approval and its execution. People now are making the link between the nation-wide ground stop of flights, the demand by the Transportation Secretary for some $50 billion to fix the system and the expenditures on the ballroom and other Trump initiatives intended to aggrandize him.

At the same time, the weakening of constitutional and institutional pillars stand on their own. Trump’s failure to follow procedure in building monuments to himself, including the new ballroom, the renaming of the Kennedy Centre, the renovation of the public golf course (see BBC, “‘Trash Island'” or DC Landmark? How a golf course got Trump in a messy legal dispute”, October 21, 2026; also see NBC News, “Judge wants former U.S. attorney to investigate whether the government misled her in Trump golf case”, November 7, 2026) and even the spending of excessive amounts of money on them are attempts to change the status of the presidency without seeking the approval of authorities, seeking approval of bodies Trump has stacked with cronies and in some cases ignoring court orders.

Attacks on alleged drug-smuggling boats, including the killing of those on board, without observing legal procedures; the family’s involvement in crypto businesses, selling pardons, Trump’s personal involvement in granting licences to media outlets, removing government watchdogs (inspectors general), the tariffs imposed on blatantly false bases (such as the threat of fentanyl crossing the border from Canada), threats against other countries, including Canada, and on and on. Some of these actions have been overturned by the courts, but many have not and they continue.

Right now, the Trump administration, still in office for the next two years, has the upper hand and its members are paving the way for painting the Democrats as merely retributive, of treating the result of their investigations as false memories. They should know, of course, because that has been their modus operandi. This will be one of the difficulties they face.

For their investigations to represent the country’s steps towards reclaiming (and improving perhaps) American democracy, the Democrats must meet a number of challenges: the lack of support from Republicans, making it easier to argue that the investigations are in the Democrats’ interests and not the national interest; a likely lack of co-operation from the Department of Justice (the Attorney General, Todd Blanche, considers himself the president’s personal lawyer, not the country’s lawyer); a lack of understanding among those who voted solely on bread and butter issues (and who do not think this is worth the effort or that Trump was doing anything wrong); among other factors. (On the DoJ point and others, see Matt Labash, “Trump. Miller. Blanche. Jordan. Things Could Get Worse, and They Probably Will,” The New York Times, November 15, 2026.)

Yes, there is a risk that some Americans, at least, may see Democratic investigations as being the same as Trump’s “retribution” (Trump has been blatant in “directing” investigations against a host of individuals, such as

      James Comey (three times, still outstanding);
      Comey’s daughter (Maureen Ryan Comey’s firing was found to be contrary to the separation of powers and due process rights);
      Cassidy Hutchinson (who testified against Trump at the January 6th inquiry and whom a grand jury decline to indict);
      Jack Smith (former special counsel whose investigative results were impeded by a judge clearly favouring Trump and by Trump’s reelection),
      Letitia James (a judge dismissed a charge of mortgage fraud but case is outstanding);
      members of congress who did a video about not following unlawful orders (Trump called this sedition and punishable by death but grand jury did not indict);
      Ilhan Omar (congresswoman, on the basis of citizenship fraud);
      Jerome Powell (former chair of the Federal Reserve who did not do Trump’s bidding on interest rates, charged with false testimony about renovations to the Fed building, eventually dropped when a judge barred subpoenas);
      Adam Schiff (a loud critic of Trump, member of January 5th committee and leader re Trump impeachment, charged with mortgage fraud);

    These individuals all in some way criticized Trump or simply did not show sufficient loyalty to him.

    The US Attorney for the District of Columbia charged David Hearn with vandalism of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool [ABC News, “Olympian David Hearn arrested at Reflecting Pool says ‘I did not damage’ anything”, June 21, 2026]). Trump blamed problems with the Pool after he hired a contractor he knew to fix it on vandals and Hearn was caught up in that; it turned out the contractor was at fault and Hearn’s case was dismissed with prejudice.

    To this list should be added Alexander Vindman who had testified against Trump in the first impeachment hearing who was subsequently removed from his position as Director for the National Security Council.

    The Democrats must distinguish in clear terms that there is a crucial difference between what Trump has done and what holding him and the administration accountable means. Trump’s retribution has been exactly that: personal, vindictive and petty use of the law against persons whom he believes wronged him or failed to be loyal to him. Holding the Trump administration accountable, in contrast, is demanded by a return to the rule of law, the basic principles of constitutionalism and restoring the institutional balance (in particular the relationship between the executive and the legislature and to the extent possible, between the executive and the judiciary).

    Moving on and focusing on the future to the exclusion of dealing with the past, ignores that that future, like Saul Rubinek’s father’s town, will be incomplete and false. It will not provide the lesson that what has happened cannot happen again. As one writer has observed, Abraham Lincoln’s “mercy” towards the South after the American Civil War is often touted as a remarkable step towards healing, although countermanded following his assassination. Leonard Pitts, has argued, however, that while Lincoln extended forgiveness, the South did not accept it. (Leonard Pitts, “What Now? What Lincoln teaches us about MAGA”, Substack, November 6, 2026)

    Trump and his cohorts have done incredible damage to the United States in a plethora of ways, both internal and external, domestically and in foreign affairs. I am not talking so much about “policies” here, but about the fundamental undermining of the rule of law and constitutional principles. The Democrats cannot ignore this damage or Trump’s and others’ contributions to it. I agree with Leonard Pitts:

    As a practical matter, the promise of justice served stands as a deterrent to those who might be tempted to do wrong. As a moral matter, it reinforces the idea that society functions in an orderly and predictable manner, that crime doesn’t pay and that at least once in awhile, those who commit misdeeds will be required to answer for them.

    For me the Rubinek/McKenna reading illuminated the importance of remembering, revealing and recording; otherwise, it is the history of the wrongdoers that is recorded as if it is right and it is that version that becomes the primary and official memory of the country and the people in it and the people to come.

    In the case of January 6th’s attack on the Capitol, for example, it did not take long before Trump acolytes began to develop a revisionist version of the events of that day. Shortly afterwards, even those who were there claimed that those pouring through the lobby and destroying objects there were merely “tourists” and that the event was peaceful. Once Donald Trump assumed the presidency again, he began the process of reinventing the attack; he pardoned those who had been convicted of injuring Capitol police, who threatened the vice-president and legislators.

    All this when there was a great deal of evidence about what really happened. Maintaining the rule of law demands that the truth be available. The January 6th investigatory committee’s report remains, even if temporarily (one hopes) there are efforts to transcend it by fabrication.

    Whose memory prevails? What happens to the victims whose experience is erased from the a country’s history. What is remembered? What is forgotten? What forms the foundation for what occurs in the future? What contributes to the definition of what the country means and aspires to? What serves to justify wrongdoing in the future? How do we ensure that history is as complete as possible? Who and what fill the vacuum when history is not as complete as possible? What happens to law when governors deliberately shun it with no consequences?

    The Democrats have an obligation to undertake the necessary investigations into the corruption by Trump and others, including, for example, deals Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have made in the course of purporting to find a solution to the Russia-Ukraine war; Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s role in weakening rules about selling computer chips to data centres that provide power to Chinese firms, a data centre run by Lutnick’s sons (New York Times, Lutnick Pushed to Weaken Chip Rules That Overlap With His Family Business, November 15, 2026) ; Trump’s conduct in threatening and bullying media, using threats such as not renewing licences, bullying law firms by terminating their security clearances (see my Slaw post, “’Let’s Kill All the Lawyers’: Trump’s EOs in the Spirit of Bills of Attainder”, April 2, 2025), the undertaking of the Iran War, the subverting of America’s relations with other western countries, perhaps never to be fully recovered and so on.

    If the Democrats fail to use the legal processes that have been established to examine conduct for wrongdoing, they will fail the nation and their obligation to show that the behaviour that has occurred during the Trump administration, with the assistance of the Republican legislators, who have allowed or even encouraged it to occur, who have abdicated their own responsibilities and who have failed to stand up, has consequences.

    The Democrats have a duty to right the course of American democracy, to restore institutional balance and to ensure adherence to the constitution, none of which can be accomplished by ignoring what has occurred under the Trump administrations. They have the legal tools American processes make available to them; if they fail to take them up, they will abdicate their duty to secure a future uncontaminated by a past that will appear to have been condoned.

Start the discussion!

Leave a Reply

(Your email address will not be published or distributed)