Column

Youth Voice – Lessons From the U.K.

I have written before about the Lundy Model of Meaningful Child Participation and about child-inclusive mediation. In this article I highlight findings of a research study by Anne Barlow and Dr. Jan Ewing exploring the use of child-inclusive mediation in England and Wales and how it is experienced by parents, children and professionals. As stated in the foreword:

The research is underscored by a firm commitment to the concept of children’s rights and to the goal of incorporating the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child into domestic law. In harnessing this commitment to their study of mediation, Anne Barlow and Jan Ewing have provided us with a wealth of data as well as presenting a convincing argument for a move away from a focus on adult autonomy in decision-making towards a more relational approach which gives due weight to the perspectives of all involved – including the children. Such an approach holds the promise of bringing about a new and fairer vision of family justice, in all its forms.

Solid data is key to transformational changes in policy and practice. While this empirical study was conducted in the U.K., there is much that can be useful for the meaningful participation movement in B.C. Here are some of the highlights:

  1. The study explores the issues from the child’s perspective.
  2. Children who had experienced child-inclusive mediation were consulted separately by the mediator as part of their parents’ family mediation process. These children were key research participants, not merely objects of decision-making. Relationship professionals and parents were also consulted.
  3. The study was conducted in response to U.K. policies implemented to encourage out-of-court settlement but, unlike court, without explicit requirements that the child should have a voice in out-of-court processes including mediation. Note 1
  4. The study advocates strongly for a shift from an emphasis on “party (parental) autonomy” in “child arrangement” (parenting plan) mediation to “relational family autonomy”, which involves the views and voices of all family members where appropriate.
  5. The study builds on the authors’ previous research which showed that invoking parental rights (or using “best interests” as a mask for parental rights) can set parents in opposition to each other, exacerbating conflict and making the mediation process less likely to succeed.”
  6. Young people passionately confirmed that children should have a right to be heard (if they wish) when parents separate, and adults must facilitate that right, listen to children’s views and act upon them.

“Just because I am a kid, it doesn’t mean that my parents’ decisions are the be- all and end- all; I do have a right. If I am uncomfortable or if I feel unsafe or whatever it is, I have a right to be heard.”

  1. The authors emphasize that a child’s capacity should be presumed, while age and understanding inform the weight given to their views.
  2. The study identified both benefits and risks of child-inclusive mediation. Benefits included:

a) Improved child wellbeing.
b) Children reported feeling reassured, respected and better informed.
c) Increased cooperation between family members.
d) Better informed arrangements. Children’s views significantly shaped agreement outcomes, fostering satisfaction, agency and ownership.
e) Alignment with international child rights standards.

  1. Risks included:

a) Children feeling pressured by parents or experiencing manipulation.
b) Children feeling an increased burden from parental conflict.
c) Harm when parents ignored children’s stated views.
d) The authors conclude that each of these risks can be mitigated or

  1. Barriers to child-inclusive mediation included:

a) Limited awareness of the process among professionals, parents and children.
b) Access problems including cost and parental fear or reluctance.
c) Mediator lack of confidence or training in child participation

  1. The study confirmed the usefulness of the Lundy Model (space, voice, audience and influence) in fulfilling children’s participation rights.
  2. It also emphasized the need for mediator training in children’s rights and child-friendly communication. It recommended efforts to increase awareness of this option and a formal code of practice for child-inclusive mediation.

The report includes dozens of candid and articulate quotations from young people with lived experience. It is worth reading for that reason alone.

I am grateful to Diana Lowe KC who brought this report to my attention.

____________

Note 1: The B.C. Family Law Act includes the views of the child as a key component of the “best interests” test for both court and out-of-court processes including mediation.

Start the discussion!

Leave a Reply

(Your email address will not be published or distributed)